Spotify 20

Culture

Spotify’s 20th anniversary look back raised an interesting question: why do so many of our most-played songs come from years ago? From changing UK music scenes to streaming overload and nostalgia, we look at why older music continues to dominate our listening.

Independent music culture portrait

Last month, Spotify celebrated its 20th anniversary. The music streaming service had a whole lineup of events and content to commemorate its birthday, leading with a new Spotify Wrapped. Usually, Spotify Wrapped consists of an end of year playlist featuring our Top 100 songs from that year, our own bespoke story featuring out listening stats such as our most listened to artists of the year and a bunch of their own Top 100 versions of their own playlists. For this 20th anniversary celebration, they gave us a mini-Wrapped focused on the user’s entire history on Spotify. It showed us our first ever listened to song, when we joined the streaming service, our most listened to artist and our Top 120 songs. 

The thing that interested me the most was ‘Your All-Time Top Songs’ playlist of Top 120 songs. When I listened through it, I has a realisation that most of the songs on my version were not recent. They were from around 2018 and before and I started to think about why. 

From a UK perspective, we have struggled with creating new genres of music. In the 90s, we created Britpop, Jungle and Garage. The 00s saw an emergence of Grime, Dubstep and Funky House. Afroswing, Drill and Hyperpop led the new wave of 10s music. Halfway through the 2020s, the UK hasn’t really created any new genres. The closest we have come is the UK Underground scene however, that is so broad, vast and varied, its doing it a disservice to label it as one genre. We have had evolutions of Drill and Grime and a renaissance in dance and bass music but those are continuations of genres from decades past and not a whole new thing. Due to this, you can always listen back to music from the origins of the genres at the forefront today whereas with a completely new genre we would have to listen today’s new output as that is all there is. This culminates in older music surpassing new music in our ‘Your All-Time Top Songs’ playlists.

Another explanation is a lot more music being uploaded to Spotify. Back in 2018, around 7 million new songs were uploaded to Spotify compared to 36 million in 2025. For the music connoisseurs and music discovery fanatics, this constant barrage of new music can be overwhelming. It becomes harder to sort though new music to find the songs and artists you like, as there is ever increasingly more to sort though. Also, it makes it harder to just keep up to date with new releases too. This can become discouraging and make use revert to our old favourites as a comfort. AI uploaded tracks have really broken the system as they upload 50,000 songs a day to the platform, exacerbating the issue further.

The last thing is the simplest, the passage of time. With older songs, we have had more time to listen to them repeatedly as they have been out for longer than newer songs. Listening to a song 100 times released last week is not normal practice however, listening to a songs 100 times released a decade ago is much more plausible as we have had the course of a decade to spread the 100 listens over. Also, we may go back to older songs as it gives us a nostalgic feeling and transports us back to the time they were released or when we discovered them. The passage of time allows us to build a deeper connection with older songs that keep us going back to them and make them dominate our ‘Your All-Time Top Songs’ playlists.

Is it just me? What do you think? Does Your All-Time Top Songs playlist favour older songs? Let us know on our socials.


Written By @bubblerby8 (Instagram)

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.